The ability of many reptilian hemoglobins (Hbs) to form high-molecular weight polymers, albeit known for decades, has not been investigated in detail. Given that turtle Hbs often contain a high number of cysteine (Cys), potentially contributing to the red blood cell defense against reactive oxygen species, we have examined whether polymerization of Hb could occur via intermolecular disulfide bonds in red blood cells of freshwater turtle Trachemys scripta, a species that is highly tolerant of hypoxia and oxidative stress. We find that one of the two Hb isoforms of the hemolysate, HbA, is prone to polymerization in vitro into linear flexible chains of different size that are visible by electron microscopy, but not the HbD isoform. Polymerization of purified HbA is favored by hydrogen peroxide, a main cellular reactive oxygen species and a thiol oxidant, and inhibited by thiol reduction and alkylation, indicating that HbA polymerization is due to disulfide bonds. By using mass spectrometry, we identify Cys5 of the α^A subunit of HbA as specifically responsible for forming disulfide bonds between adjacent HbA tetramers. Polymerization of HbA does not affect oxygen affinity, cooperativity and sensitivity to the allosteric cofactor ATP, indicating that HbA is still fully functional. Polymers also form in T. scripta blood after exposure to anoxia but not normoxia, indicating that they are of physiologically relevance. Taken together, these results show that HbA polymers may form during oxidative stress and that Cys5α^A of HbA is a key element of the antioxidant capacity of turtle red blood cells.