One third of diabetes mellitus patients develop diabetic nephropathy and with underlying mechanisms unknown it is imperative that diabetic animal models resemble human disease. The present study investigated the susceptibility to develop diabetic nephropathy in four commonly used and commercially available mouse strains with type 1 diabetes in order to determine the suitability of each strain. Type 1 diabetes was induced in C57Bl/6, NMRI, BALB/c and 129Sv mice by alloxan and conscious glomerular filtration rate, proteinuria and oxidative stress levels were measured in control and diabetic animals at baseline and after five and ten weeks. Histological alterations were analyzed using periodic acid-Schiff staining. Diabetic C57Bl/6 displayed increased glomerular filtration rate, i.e. hyperfiltration, whereas all other parameters remained unchanged. Diabetic NMRI developed the most pronounced hyperfiltration as well as increased oxidative stress and proteinuria, but without glomerular damage. Diabetic BALB/c did not develop hyperfiltration, but presented with pronounced proteinuria, increased oxidative stress and glomerular damage. Diabetic 129Sv displayed proteinuria and increased oxidative stress without glomerular hyperfiltration or damage. However, all strains displayed intra-strain correlation between oxidative stress and proteinuria. In conclusion, diabetic C57Bl/6 and NMRI both developed glomerular hyperfiltration, but neither presented with histological damage, although NMRI developed low-degree proteinuria. Thus, these strains may be suitable when investigating the mechanism causing hyperfiltration. Neither BALB/c nor 129Sv developed hyperfiltration although both developed pronounced proteinuria. However, only BALB/c developed detectable histological damage. Thus, BALB/c may be suitable when studying the roles of proteinuria and histological alterations for the progression of diabetic nephropathy.