Mixed race scholarship considers the deployment of the term "mixed race" as an identification and theorizes that the operation of the external racial gaze is signaled through the "what are you?" question that mixed race people face in their everyday lives. In interviews conducted with mixed race, young adults in a Western Canadian urban context, it was evident that the "what are you?" question is the verbal form of the external racial gaze’s production of ambivalence on mixed race bodies. However, this study also found that mixed race people have "ready" identity narratives in response to the "what are you?" question. This paper shows the importance of these narratives (the very existence of the "ready" narratives, as well as the content of the "ready" narrative) for fleshing out the operation of the external racial gaze in the Canadian context. Respondents draw on two closely related modes of narrating origin when responding to the "what are you?" question: they respond through a kinship narrative that is heteronormative and they narrate that they inherit "national origin" "through blood." I argue that these responses point to how the gaze produces the multiracialized body through the desire to imagine and "know" its originary point of racial mixing. Yet, the "ready" narratives are also agential: while at times they narrate to the expectations of the gaze, they also "play on" the gaze.