["Psychology &Marketing, EarlyView. ", "\nABSTRACT\nUnderstanding food consumption behavior is a priority for nutritionists, policymakers, and marketers. This research highlights an overlooked aspect of such behavior, namely, the design of the tools used for consumption. We argue that the length of a cutlery item's handle, while holding the size of the functional part (e.g., spoon bowl) constant, can affect consumers' perceptions of motor fluency and eating pace, which in turn shape consumption quantity. Across seven studies and three supplementary studies (N = 2506), we provide converging evidence that the cutlery handle prompts expectations about how fluency and eating speed perceptions unfold, and, through this mechanism, affects how much consumers expect to consume. The paper further examines the prevalence of the cutlery handle effect under relevant contextual factors, including product characteristics (healthy vs. unhealthy product category) and the situational context (eating in a hurry vs. not). The cutlery handle effect is more consistent when eating speed is situationally salient, such as under time pressure, and for healthy products. These findings illustrate how subtle design features of eating tools may affect consumers' anticipation of the eating process. From a managerial standpoint, cutlery design is part of a broader eating environment that shapes consumption experiences and quantity.\n"]